A Good Girl's Guide to Murder Season 2 Scores 96% on Rotten Tomatoes — Here's Why Everyone Is Binge-Watching It Right Now

A Good Girl's Guide to Murder Season 2 Is Netflix's Hottest New Hit

If you haven't heard about A Good Girl's Guide to Murder yet, consider this your official wake-up call. Season 2 of the Netflix mystery series dropped on May 27, 2026, and it's already racked up a staggering 96% Rotten Tomatoes audience score. That's not just good — that's elite-tier territory, especially for a show that doesn't come from a massive franchise like Marvel or Stranger Things.

Based on Holly Jackson's wildly popular YA mystery novel series, the show follows high schooler Pippa Fitz-Amobi, played by Emma Myers (yes, the same scene-stealer from Wednesday). Season 1 had Pippa investigating a closed murder case in her small Connecticut town for a school project. Season 2? Things get even darker, and audiences are absolutely eating it up.

What Makes Season 2 So Good?

Without spoiling too much, Season 2 tackles the mystery of what happened to Jamie Reynolds, played by Eden H. Davies — the brother of Connor (portrayed by Jude Morgan-Collie). The season picks up right where the first left off, and according to the Cosmopolitan breakdown, the finale delivers a devastating emotional punch that has fans flooding social media.

What sets this show apart from other YA mystery dramas like Pretty Little Liars or One of Us Is Lying is its grounded approach. There's no supernatural hand-waving — just solid detective work, real consequences, and genuinely shocking twists. Emma Myers proves once again that she's not just a Wednesday one-note wonder. She carries this show with a magnetic blend of vulnerability and fierce determination that makes you root for Pippa every step of the way.

What About Season 3?

Here's the good news: Holly Jackson's book series has four books total, meaning there's plenty of source material for more seasons. At the time of writing, Netflix hasn't officially greenlit Season 3 — no double-season order was announced after Season 1, which is a bummer — but the math is pretty compelling.

You've got a lead actress with massive name recognition thanks to Wednesday on Netflix, a devoted fanbase that's already giving Season 2 a 96% audience score, and a relatively modest production budget compared to sci-fi epics. With two more books to adapt, it would be genuinely surprising if Netflix didn't pull the trigger on Season 3 eventually.

For now, the entire Season 2 is streaming on Netflix — all episodes available as of the May 27 debut. If you missed Season 1, now's the perfect time to catch up before Season 3 potentially drops. Both seasons currently hold exceptional critic and audience scores on Rotten Tomatoes, which is a rare feat for any show, let alone a YA mystery adaptation.

Bottom line: If you're looking for your next binge obsession after finishing something like The Night Agent or Black Mirror, A Good Girl's Guide to Murder Season 2 is an easy and brilliant pick. Trust us on this one.